You're the Critic (comments and reviews on A Key Keepers Mystery)

This book is definitely a keeper.... (1/12/2007) (originally posted on Amazon.com)
"Great educational mystery novel, I enjoyed reading it just as much as my 10 year old son, we both enjoyed it even though mystery novels are not his genre, they are mine! Highly recommended for family or classroom reading. Looking forward to more books from this author."

As reviewed by Joyce Rice of Lake Worth, FL (5/1/2007): "As a 30 year veteran of children's literature, I recommend this book for reading together or as a class project. Not only will students enjoy the characterization of Emma, Maddie and Michael, but they will also learn about the geographics of the setting of the story. Readers will be eager to be just one step ahead of the adventure-seeking trio. This is a series to take note of for middle readers. A great effort for a beginning author." (originally posted on Amazon.com)

As reviewed by Cheryl White, Library Media Specialist: "It is my pleasure to recommend Liz Shore's novel, A Key Keepers Mystery: The Game Begins. From the first pages, I was caught in the mystery of Uncle Jack's deathbed revelations to his great-niece, Emma. Her mother, Nanette, is a professional who has little time for fun with her daughter and barely arrives at Uncle Jack's bedside to hear his last words. Life changes drastically for the mother and daughter as Uncle Jack's will reveals a new direction for Nanette as a full-time caregiver . . . . With the use of dialogue and adventure, the author keeps the reader's attention and interest. Emma, Madeline, and Michael are individuals with the emotions and imaginations of children today. Even their plan to pursue the solution to the mystery by flying to a deserted island by tricking Nanette . . . is believable and entices the reader to keep reading! An added bonus to the mystery story is the author's use of geographical and historical descriptions throughout the novel. The reader will learn about St. Augustine, the Everglades, and Key West. An introduction to Ernest Hemingway and his cats could even provide the interest to learn more about one of America's greatest authors. As an elementary school library media specialist, I know how students love a mystery story and how difficult it can be to provide exciting and well-written books. Liz Shore's first novel is one the students should enjoy. I believe they will keep asking for more about the adventures of Emma, Madeline, and Michael."

As reviewed by Caitlyn Dlouhy, Senior Editor for Atheneum Books for Young Readers: "I read your manuscript with interest, and while I'm sorry to say that this particular piece isn't right for our list here at Atheneum, I did enjoy your writing and would be glad to look at other work from you in the future. I was glad for the opportunity to consider your work, and it is with regret that I am passing on this project."

As reviewed by Phoebe Roy of Silver Dagger Mysteries: "It is extremely well written and very interesting. The plot was exciting and the characters were very interesting."

As reviewed by Reading teacher, S. Cary (12/6/2006): "I read your book this past weekend and couldn't put it down. It is terrific!!!!! I am so impressed with how the mystery and history was intertwined. I was surprised with [the ending]- I didn't see it coming. It is a very clever concept and the way you ended the book to lead to another one is great. Although it is written for kids, I thoroughly enjoyed it as an adult. Oh to be a teacher in Florida......."

As reviewed by elementary teacher, E. Headrick (1/22/07): "I thoroughly enjoyed your book. I read the book in a week. I couldn’t put it down. I’m ready to find out what happens next!"

As reviewed by reader, S. Roberts (10/3/2006): "Congratulations on a job well done. I hope you plan to write another one . . . . I've lived in Florida all my life and you taught me several things I did not know. Another confession: I've never been to Key West . . . . We will get there one of these days and because of your book I will appreciate the trip all the more. "

As reviewed by ETSU instructor of School Library Media, C. Hasbrouck (10/1/2006): "I read the book...straight through with just a break to fix something to eat. Very readable!!!!"

One parent writes (1/30/07): "My son enjoyed your book immensely. He was telling people at church about it and how cool it was. I'm expecting it to be great given how it kept his attention. He's never been big on reading but lately that seems to be changing for the better! "

As reviewed by reader, Virginia McLean (1/31/07): "The Game Begins is well written and expertly researched, combining clarity, humor, human interest, and suspense--highly recommended for children and adults."

Kayla S., a former student writes (2/4/07): "I loved your book so much I remembered every detail. Well almost. I'm so proud of you!! Did you know I never liked reading until 4th grade? Your book inspired me to keep reading and to love books. We still have to do AR in 6th grade and my AR goal is the highest on Bear Hall. We are so very proud of you."

As reviewed by K. Hendley of the North Brevard Home School Association (3/19/07): "I thoroughly enjoyed your book. I read it in two evenings. I loved the way the children all found a common bond and began to work together. You kept me guessing until the very end. I kept wondering how you were going to conclude the story and tie up the loose ends. You wrapped up enough of the details that I was very satisfied but can say that I am looking forward to the next adventure."

Reader Rebecca K. writes (3/30/07): "I absolutely loved your book. The way you kept the suspense up . . . until the end was great. Half the time I couldn't put down the book! It was so weird. I was in Florida while I read that book, and I learned where the keys are!!"

Reader Lauren M. from St. Cloud, FL, writes (11/5/07): "I loved the book. It was better than The Harry Potter Books (she read all of them). The reason your book was better was because it was modern and could happen." (note from mom: she stayed up to 2 a.m. to finish it!)